Tank Water Heater Reviews

Tank water heaters are old standbys, and if you purchase one that has a reliable pilot light or is self-cleaning or energy-efficient, then you can often install it yourself and not worry about it for a decade.

These heaters come in several sizes, but the vast majority of them are meant for medium or large homes that have families which take multiple showers at the same time and run the dishwasher too, for instance.

As tankless heaters have made serious inroads into the water heater market, manufacturers of tank water heaters have strived to make their products more miserly when it comes to electricity and gas.

Many of the prominent brands in this category make gas, propane and electric models; people buy one or the other based on how their home is wired or on the type of power supply that they prefer. Some consumers simply don’t like gas, while others appreciate the consistent savings that gas gives them compared to high electric bills.

As you shop in this category, consider the space that you have and whether or not you want to go gas or electric, or even liquid propane. This group of water heaters can be considered the traditional choice, with recent makeovers that are aimed at making them more green as homeowners care more about their emissions and bills.

Tank Water Heater Reviews – High to low Ratings

Rheem 42VR40-40F

Rheem 42VR40-40F High Efficiency Natural Gas Water Heater, 40 Gallon

Rating: (4.7 out of 5 stars)
With the rising cost of utility bills, value-for-money is top of mind among consumers when choosing appliances for the home. And the Rheem 42VR40-40F Natural Gas Water Heater fits the bill perfectly. This 40 gallon High Efficiency water heater packs a punch, offering … [ more ]
Brand:Rheem
Price Indication:
$480 – $530

Reliance 6 2 SSUS K

Reliance 6 2 SSUS K 2.5 Gallon Electric Water Heater

Rating: (4.7 out of 5 stars)
Finding a water heater appropriate for small spaces is not a problem anymore, now there’s the Reliance 6 2 SSUS K. This very compact electric water hater supplies 2.5 gallons of water, just enough for a single sink or very low flow application. Because it … [ more ]
Price Indication:
$170 – $190

Stiebel Eltron SHC 2.5

Stiebel Eltron SHC 2.5 Mini-Tank Electric Water Heater, 2.5 Gallon

Rating: (4.5 out of 5 stars)
Mini-tank water heaters are gaining popularity because point-of-use units are economical and do not require complicated wiring to install. The Stiebel Eltron SHC is one such mini-tank water heater. Electric-powered, this model has a … [ more ]
Price Indication:
$200 – $220

Eemax EMT4

Eemax EMT4 4 Gallon Capacity Electric Mini-Tank

Rating: (4.5 out of 5 stars)
The Eemax EMT 4 Electric Mini-Tank is a higher capacity version of the EMT2.5 and holds 4 gallons of water. This point-of-use mini-tank is powered by electricity and can be installed on the floor or mounted to a wall (brackets are included in the package)… [ more ]
Brand:Eemax
Price Indication:
$170 – $190

Bosch GL6 Ariston

Bosch GL6 Ariston 6-Gallon Point-of-Use Indoor Electric Mini-Tank Water Heater

Rating: (4.4 out of 5 stars)
For RV owners looking to replace their water heaters that use propane as fuel, the answer may lie in the Bosch GL6 Ariston Indoor Electric Mini-Tank Water Heater. You don’t need to worry about your RV catching fire because the unit uses electricity… [ more ]
Brand:Bosch
Price Indication:
$180 – $200

Rheem 81VP20S

Rheem 81VP20S Electric Point-of-Use Water Heater, 20 Gallon

Rating: (4.4 out of 5 stars)
When it comes to water heaters, one of the top brands that come to mind is Rheem. Its highly reliable units do not disappoint, and this reliability can also be expected from its electric point-of-use water heaters. The 81VP20S is a compact and convenient … [ more ]
Brand:Rheem
Price Indication:
$350 – $380

Rheem MR85245

Rheem MR85245 Marathon 85 Gal. Tall Electric Water Heater

Rating: (4.3 out of 5 stars)
Just when you thought you’ve seen everything in the water heating industry, Rheem comes out with a rust- and corrosion-resistant tank water heater. Known as the Marathon series, this non-metallic tank-style water heater is made of polybutene that is … [ more ]
Brand:Rheem
Price Indication:
$1100 – $1200

Rheem 42VR50-40F

Rheem 42VR50-40F High Efficiency Natural Gas Water Heater, 50 Gallon

Rating: (4.3 out of 5 stars)
For those looking for high capacity water heaters that use natural gas as fuel, try the Rheem 42VR50 that supplies 50 gallons of water. This high efficiency heater is maintenance free as it has no filters. And similar to other Fury Gas Series models … [ more ]
Brand:Rheem
Price Indication:
$530 – $580

Bosch GL4 Ariston

Bosch GL4 Ariston 4-Gallon Point-of-Use Indoor Electric Mini-Tank Water Heater

Rating: (4.2 out of 5 stars)
The Bosch GL4 Ariston is a point-of-use water heater that allows you to immediately enjoy hot water where you need it — be it your kitchen sink or shower. You can install this unit independently or link it with your main water … [ more ]
Brand:Bosch
Price Indication:
$170 – $190

Bradford White M250T6DS-1NCWW

Bradford White M250T6DS-1NCWW 50 Gallon Electric Water Heater - Tall Model

Rating: (4.1 out of 5 stars)
As part of Bradford White’s tall electric models classified as Energy Saver, the M250T6DS-1NCWW Electric Water Heater exemplifies the power of the Hydrojet® Total Performance System. This system includes a device in the cold water inlet that reduces … [ more ]
Price Indication:
$500 – $550

Rheem 22V50F1

Rheem 22V50F1 Natural Gas Water Heater, 50 Gallon

Rating: (4.1 out of 5 stars)
The Rheem 22V50F1 is a member of the Rheem Fury Gas Series which offers economical yet effective hot water solutions. Thanks to its design, maintenance of this water heater is a breeze; it doesn’t have any filters that need to be cleaned or replaced. Another big plus is … [ more ]
Brand:Rheem
Price Indication:
$400 – $450

Rheem 22V40F1

Rheem 22V40F1 Natural Gas Water Heater, 40 Gallon

Rating: (4.1 out of 5 stars)
Rheem’s Fury Gas Series was designed to provide consumers with affordable yet efficient solutions to meet their hot water requirements. And the Rheem 22V40FI Natural Gas Water Heater, which provides 40 gallons, is one of them. With the patented … [ more ]
Brand:Rheem
Price Indication:
$350 – $400

Bosch GL2.5 Ariston

Bosch GL2.5 Ariston 2-1/2-Gallon Point-of-Use Indoor Electric Mini-Tank Water Heater

Rating: (4.1 out of 5 stars)
Tired of waiting for hot water to arrive at your sink but can’t afford a tankless water heater? You should try the Bosch GL2.5 Ariston Mini-Tank Water Heater. Similar to a tankless water heater, this 2 ½ gallon Ariston is installed at point-of-use … [ more ]
Brand:Bosch
Price Indication:
$160 – $180

Rheem HP50RH

Rheem HP50RH Heat Pump Water Heater, 50 Gallon

Rating: (4.0 out of 5 stars)
Households and commercial establishments in hot and warm climates can benefit from using water heaters that involve heat pump technology. This latest innovation in water heating combines the best features of tank and tankless water heaters which results in … [ more ]
Brand:Rheem
Price Indication:
$1300 – $1400

Coleman Portable Water Heater

Coleman Hot Water-On-Demand Portable Water Heater

Rating: (4.0 out of 5 stars)
Having hot water during camping trips is difficult if you don’t have a portable water heater. Among the brands in the market today that provide you with this luxury is the Coleman Hot Water-On-Demand Portable Water Heater. It comes with a … [ more ]
Brand:Coleman
Price Indication:
$200 – $220

Eemax EMT2.5

Eemax EMT2.5 2.5-Gallon Electric Mini-Tank

Rating: (4.0 out of 5 stars)
If you wait for your tap water to get hot because your water heater is situated far from the sink, you might want to consider buying the Eemax EMT2.5 Electric Mini-Tank Water Heater. This 2.5 gallon point-of-use water heater provides … [ more ]
Brand:Eemax
Price Indication:
$150 – $170

Reliance 6 6 SOMS K

Reliance 6 6 SOMS K 6 Gallon Compact Electric Water Heater

Rating: (3.8 out of 5 stars)
If you are looking for an electric water heater that will fit in nicely under the counter or a crawl space, you might want to check out the Reliance 6 6 SOMS K Electric Water Heater. This 120 volt compact heater has a … [ more ]
Brand:Reliance
Price Indication:
$180 – $200